Denis O'Hare

Wally

Dwight Cochrane

Dr. Edmund Hague

Simon Haysmith

Lucius Reeve

Officer Lonergan

Brad

Dr. Dordick

Craddock

John Morse

Archbishop

Tyr, Tyr / Tyrell

Agent Doss

Jessie

Doc Morris

Hiram Keebler

Special Agent Robert Phillips

Self

Albert Osborne

Holden Vaughn, Spalding, Stanley, Larry Harvey, Elias Cunningham, Liz Taylor, Dr. Elias Cunningham / Actor William Van Henderson, Henry, Dr. Andrew Hill

Lotorius

Moore

Mr. Gilbertson

Phillip Steele

Russel, Russell Edgington

Financial News Analyst

Smith

Mr. Greer

John Bussey

Travis March

Jimbo

Jerry the Lawyer

Unknown role

Judge Charles Abernathy

Dr. Rothberg

Osric

Jake

Jimmy Walp, Father Chris Shea

Father Richard Hogan, Harold Morrissey, Phil Christie, James Smith

Edgar Allan Poe