Bruce McGill

Mayor Grover Teale

Jim Foster

Wayne Bisbee

Milt

Chief Carl

Carvie Oldham

Pat Mullen

Edwin Stanton

Randy Fox

Detective Miller

Stanley Gordon

John Williams (voice)

Santa Claus (voice)

Detective Vince Korsak

Jim Pavitt

Jonas Cantrell

Ben Summers

George Tenet

Marty Kopac

Phil McCullough

Robert Pratt

Daniel Simpson Day (D-Day)

Dan Trombly

Godfrey

Judge (voice)

Jeremy Breslow

National Security Advisor Revell

Bradley

General McCormick (voice)

Reverend Larson

Walter Hagen

Gordon Garrison

William

Lincoln's Cabinet Member (voice), Santa Claus (voice), John Williams (voice), (voice)

T.C. Bryant

Duke Purdy

Captain Braxton

Boone Waxwell

Mike Matthews

Weird Ernie, Al the Bartender

Willard Cates, Dr. Sokolov

Dave the Fireman

Dan Darwell

Charlie

W. Shaw (uncredited)

Mace Hurley

Luigi "Lou" Paloma

Brian Ferguson

Daniel Simpson Day