Will Forte

Kevin Avery

Martin Marvin

Nathan

Jack

Coach Dan

Gilbert Power

Warden

Abe Lincoln

Darren Sandelbaum

MacGruber

Abraham Lincoln (voice)

Richard Fox / Pubba

Shel

Wolf Tobin

Dawa

Shaggy Rogers (voice)

Self

Tim Willoughby (voice)

Jann Melfi

Christian Winter

Max's Dad

Doug Kenney

Bagpipe Player

Pastor Fontaine

Red Cunningham (voice), Rad Cunningham

Cody (voice)

Phil Tandy Miller

Derelict (uncredited)

'Previously' Narrator / Football Announcer (voice) (uncredited)

Self

Self

Male Cheerleader (uncredited)

Edwin Booth

Sergeant Bressman

Phil

Allan Bishopman

Reed

Glenn

Self

Self

MacGruber

Horace the Lone Diner

Kelly

Dean Solomon

Himself

Paul L'astnamé, Tomas

Randy

Security Guard (voice), Butt Insurance Salesman (voice), Convention Attendee (voice), Mayor Woodside (voice), Charlie Greenfield (voice), Firefighter Henry Watkins (voice), Jesus Christ (voice)

Kirk Cameron (voice)

Policeman

Self - Guest

Ben

King Toot (voice)

Husband, Referee, Band Member, Robotron, MacGruber, Wolf Man, Self - Various Characters, Self - Host, Self - Cameo (uncredited), Department Head, Self, Will Forte

Additional Voices (voice)

Chipper (voice)